Practical ideas from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe · Free issue · Send us your shop tip
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home / Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001)

4020’s Weak Spindle Problem Solved

Featured source:

Norman Fiddler, Webb, Saskatchewan, really likes the old 4020 John Deere he uses as a loader and chore tractor, but he got tired of repairing broken spindles.

“My dad bought the tractor new in 1968, so it has sentimental value, too,” he says.

“I’d broken spindles four or five times, usually when loading big bales with the front end loader. Once, while raking hay, the spindle broke on one side, and before I could even push in the clutch, it had put enough side pressure on the other one that it snapped, too,” he says.

Fiddler’s breaking point came when a spindle broke and chipped about an inch and a half notch out of the axle where the bearing mounted, forcing him to have to go back about 2 1/2 miles home in the snow, using the bucket as a runner to keep the front end off the ground.

Fiddler decided there had to be a way to solve the weak spindle problem without giving up his 4020. He talked it over with his Deere dealer, who helped him find a wrecked 5010 Deere with the front end intact. He knew the 5010 front end was heavier and wider.

Fiddler had a local machine shop cut the saddle plate to the same width as the one on the 4020. Then he took the plate off the 4020 and cut holes in the 5010 plate to match.

When he bolted the 5010 saddle plate in place, he used heavier bolts than the ones Deere used originally.

The brackets for power steering cylinders on the 5010 were cast into the rear motor mount brackets, so he had to make new brackets for the 4020.

“I made new brackets from heavy flat iron and bolted them to holes I drilled in the frame of the 4020,” he says.

“At first, I used the 10.00 x 16 tires that were originally on the 4020, but because of the way the 5010 axle is made, the front end of the tractor sat lower. I replaced the tires with 11.00 x 16 tires and now the hood is level,” he says.

“Steering and handling is still the same as original, but I think it has a shorter turning radius.

“I can lift as much on the front end loader as the hydraulics will allow without worrying about spindle or axle failure. Also, the wider stance gives the tractor better stability when lifting, loading and moving large round bales. I can even carry two large round bales on the loader if the terrain allows it,” he says.

Contact: FARM SHOW Followup, Norman Fiddler, Box 97, Webb, Sask., Canada S0N 2X0 (ph 306 672-3921).

Reproduced from the published FARM SHOW entry. Prices, coupons, availability and contact details are historical, not current offers. Reader methods are not universal instructions: follow manufacturer guidance, proper supports and safety practices, and consult a qualified professional when needed.

Comments and votes

Have you tried this idea? Mark it helpful and share how it worked in your shop.